Receive Complimentary Property Valuation

❮ Back to News

Vacation Rentals vs. Year-Round Tenants?

Vacation Rentals vs. Year-Round Tenants?

June 1, 2024

Vacation Rentals vs. Year-Round Tenants: Which Is Best For Your Multifamily Property

Deciding between vacation rentals and year-round tenants for your multifamily property is a crucial choice that can significantly impact your investment’s profit. Vacation rentals offer the potential for higher income through short-term stays, appealing to tourists and business travelers and providing flexibility in pricing and occupancy. On the other hand, year-round tenants ensure a stable and consistent cash flow with less turnover and potentially lower management costs. Each option has its own set of advantages and challenges. Also, understanding these can help property owners make an informed decision that aligns with their financial goals and lifestyle preferences.


Benefits of Vacation Rentals

Vacation rentals offer several benefits for multifamily property owners, highlighted below.

  • Flexibility in pricing: Owners can adjust rental rates based on demand, maximizing income during high-demand periods.
  • Reduced wear and tear: Short-term stays often result in less wear and tear on the property compared to long-term occupancy, as vacationers typically spend less time in the rental.
  • Frequent maintenance: Regular cleaning and maintenance between guests ensure the property remains in excellent condition, potentially reducing long-term repair costs.
  • Tax benefits: In some regions, specific tax advantages are available for properties used as short-term rentals.
  • Market responsiveness: Owners can quickly respond to market trends and adjust their rental strategy, amenities, and pricing to meet evolving guest expectations.


Cons of Vacation Rentals

  • Higher management costs: Vacation rentals often require more intensive management due to frequent guest turnover, including cleaning, maintenance, and administrative tasks.
  • Regulatory compliance: Vacation rentals may be subject to stricter local regulations and zoning laws, potentially leading to legal complications or fines.
  • Insurance costs: Obtaining appropriate insurance for vacation rentals can be more expensive and complicated than long-term rental policies.


Benefits of Year-Round Rentals

Year-round rentals for multifamily properties offer the top benefits highlighted below.

  • Stable income: Continuous occupancy ensures a consistent and predictable revenue stream, reducing the financial uncertainty that can come with seasonal or short-term rentals.
  • Lower turnover costs: Longer leases mean fewer tenant turnovers, which minimizes the costs associated with cleaning, maintenance, marketing, and administrative work between tenants.
  • Enhanced property condition: Long-term tenants are more likely to take care of the property, resulting in less wear and tear compared to properties with high turnover rates.
  • Predictable budgeting: With a stable income, property owners can better plan and allocate funds for maintenance, improvements, and other expenses.
  • Less regulatory scrutiny: Long-term rentals are often subject to fewer regulations and restrictions compared to short-term rentals, which can be heavily regulated in some areas.


Cons of Year-Round Rentals 

  • Increased wear and tear: Continuous occupancy means more wear and tear on the property, leading to higher maintenance and repair costs.
  • Potential for difficult tenants: Year-round rentals might attract tenants who could be more challenging to manage. This leads to issues such as non-payment of rent, property damage, or disturbances to other tenants.
  • Impact on property value: High tenant turnover and wear and tear can negatively affect the property’s long-term value, making it less attractive to potential buyers or investors.


Looking To Find A Multifamily Property To Create Short-Term & Long-Term Investments? Contact The Multifamily Firm Today!

If you have any questions regarding the multifamily sector of real estate in Florida and beyond or are searching for a property to add to your portfolio, the team at The Multifamily Firm would be thrilled to discuss them with you. We are a premier investment real estate brokerage focusing solely on the disposition & acquisition of multifamily properties. To learn more and speak with one of our team members, please feel free to contact us via our contact form or call us at 941-444-6160.